Home Search
Service Verify: How Not to Slip on a Banana Skin
Talking of beginnings the immortal Douglas Adams said:

“In the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and been widely regarded as a bad move.”

I know of a friend who had the same attitude towards her broadband Internet installation. One exciting September morning in 2004 an engineer turned up on her doorstep, hammer drill in hand, brandishing a shiny new broadband modem (this in the days before broadband wireless routers were de rigueur). After about half an hour of knocking tentatively at walls before driving the hammer drill through them with wild abandon the engineer happily announced that my friend was installed and pointed proudly to her internet connection on her PC. Marveling at the breathtaking speed that made her narrowband connection seem like a bad dream, my friend proceeded to spend the rest of the day delighting in all the entertainment and information that the Internet had to offer.

The following morning she came and sat down at her PC, coffee in hand, expecting to do a little research on architectural styles in East London in the 1950’s (sic), only to be greeted by Internet Explorer dropping connection every 15 minutes and speeds that, whilst better than narrowband, were certainly not the broadband speeds she’d been reveling in.

There followed three months of painful calls to the call centre where she would explain the problem, the support engineer would check her line and see she had a connection then tell her that she was clearly mistaken or possibly insane. Finally my friend lost her temper with the support engineer, being Irish/Italian by heritage believe me when I say that this is a sight to behold, and the following day an engineer was dispatched to her home to discover what was going wrong.

On arrival he pulled out a little black box with a dial on the front and connecting it up to her cable frowned a little and started fiddling with the screws on the wall socket. On removing the cover he tutted briefly to himself and fiddled around with a screw driver for a couple of minutes and as if by magic my friends problem was solved.

So what had gone wrong? The problem was a fairly simple one, and relatively well understood in cable land. The tap screws in the tap simply hadn’t been tightened appropriately and were badly connected. For the techies reading this that translated into a poor signal to noise ratio which in turn meant that about 60-80% of my friends IP packets were being dropped; little wonder her connection was so poor. Two months later a competing cheaper internet product was brought out by the incumbent telco and my friend switched her allegiances.

The above was obviously a horrible customer experience, but what could have been done to prevent it? The obvious answer is that a check should have been done to make sure that the physical characteristics of her connection were within recommended levels before the engineer left her house. In the case of ADSL installations where the majority of the time a self install is conducted then triggering a line check at the end of an automated installation process would achieve roughly the same results.

The reason why most cable companies don’t run these sorts of checks on install is because it requires a piece of equipment called a spectrum analyzer. They’re expensive and installers would have to be trained in their use. However, there is another way to get at this information; the cable modem knows about its signal to noise ratio (SNR) (in the ADSL world the modem knows about the “line attenuation” that, without getting into technical detail, measures much the same thing). If a piece of equipment was installed at the telecommunications company that could query the modem and discover if it’s parameters were within recommended operating thresholds then inform the installation engineer, he could leave the property confident that the customer had a good installation.

A similar automated check could be conducted on line (assuming a connection could be made at all) by a customer running a self-install so they could ensure their installation was good. Not only would this cut down on customers dissatisfied with intermittent line problems but at the same time it would give the customer a warm fuzzy feeling that they had carried out their installation correctly.

It goes almost without saying that being able to visualize and threshold modem parameters at the call center is invaluable for support engineers. Engineers need a simple interface that can tell them:

•    What a certain parameter such as Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) is.
•    Whether it is between appropriate threshold values.
•    What to do about it if parameters are below threshold limits.

Remote rebooting of the modem is also very useful when debugging this sort of problem.

This is exactly what Consona’s Service Verify product does. It’s tried and tested in the market and provides digital service providers with a surety that their customers are getting the best possible installation they can. It also helps them maintain that level of surety throughout the customer’s lifecycle.

If you have any questions regarding Service Verification you can contact the Digital Optimist at orhan.ertughrul@consona.com. For more information on how Consona can help you implement a market leading Service Verification process contact x and we’ll be happy to help you.

The Quiet Revolution – 2nd Generation Desktop Agents
Every now and then a technological innovation arrives on our doorstep that revolutionizes the way we think about computing and telecommunications; the iPhone, wireless LAN communications, broadband Internet, dedicated GPUs, and for those old enough to remember, the ZX80 and 81 are a few examples. The impact of these inventions tends to be immediate and easily recognizable.

However, the development of some equally ground-breaking technologies proceeds more by evolution than by revolution and it is only with the benefit of hindsight that we see its true impact. Perhaps one of the best examples of this is the Internet, a military and academic oddity for exchanging data until the advent of the first browsers (hands up all those that remember hand coding HTML for NCSA Mosaic). With the appearance of the browser there was suddenly a way to make information easily accessible to all in a format that didn’t just appeal to the high brow and we now have one of the technological miracles of our age.

Perhaps less ground shaking but similar in principle is the quiet revolution that is happening on the desktop of our computers as various software and service providers vie for our attention. Organisations are starting to realize that “Desktop Estate” is a valuable commodity and one that, if used wisely, can enhance the experience of the customer and generate substantial value for the provider.

The principle is simple, rather than provide customers with information and services through a website you provide access to a more focused portfolio of activities through an application on the desktop of their PC. So why move to this sort of model rather than stick to the tried and tested formula of providing services through a website? For several very good reasons:

  • Immediacy – The web is a “pull” medium, a company advertises its website through conventional marketing methods and then hopes the customer visits when they need to interact. The desktop is a very different environment, it’s a “push” medium, it’s immediate, applications can be accessed at the click of a button and information can be placed directly in front of a customer by the provider if the right desktop software product is installed.
  • Targeting – If you’re an application that sits on the customer’s desktop then you know about that computer; what applications are being run, what problems are occurring, what preferences a user has selected and what devices are attached. This allows you to provide targeted information and services to the customer.
  • Control – Running on the PC gives you access to the system registry and all other operational systems within the PC. This allows for troubleshooting, performance optimization, services management, installation management and various other useful operations.

So what does all this add up to and how does it fulfill the needs of the Digital Service Provider (DSP)? In the past, most desktop agents have fulfilled a purely support role providing pro-active support for easy to solve issues around connectivity and email. This is no longer enough. DSPs have to abandon the old paradigm of pro-active support and adopt a new paradigm of “total desktop service”. How does this differ from the old support paradigm?

  • Advanced Contextual Support – most 1st generation Desktop Support Agents could detect fault conditions and provide an automatic resolution. A 2nd generation Desktop Support Agent now needs to be able to detect the configuration of the customer’s machine and present them with support flows and information based on this configuration. In other words, the service experience is tailored to the customer and their environment.
  • Unifying the Application Space – As Digital Service Providers provide more value added services (VAS) there is the potential to have a wide range of mini-applications that each provides elements of service to the customer. This “Application Space” is disparate and distributed, and in many cases even differently branded. The 2nd generation desktop agent needs to be able to manage installation of these services and then act as a point of aggregation that unifies the application space with each application being able to be launched from the agent.
  • Delivering “Service Center” Functionality – Most DSPs have a “My Services” page associated with their website that provides authenticated access to account services. These are useful because subscribers that know how to use this facility can do so and hence avoid having to ring the call center. Generally the subscriber can make account changes here far faster than they could do over the phone. The problem is that “My Services” pages tend to be under-utilized. They suffer from the “pull” nature of the website relying on the subscriber to know where the services are and how to use them. A “My Services” service built into a desktop agent doesn’t suffer from this drawback.
  • Desktop Messaging – As an important function of 1st generation desktop agents, this continues to be a powerful feature of 2nd generation agents with the amendment that 2nd generation desktop agents also provide powerful targeting functionality to allow service and marketing messages to become more personalised.
  • Driving Revenue – As Average Revenue Per Unit (ARPU) is threatened by product commoditization and greater competition in the marketplace, strategies have to be found to sell more to the current subscriber base. A 2nd generation agent facilitates this through targeted contextual marketing. For instance, during agent installation the desktop agent can check whether a security system such as AVS or Norton is installed and if it isn’t the application can give the customer the opportunity to purchase one. This potentially improves the customer’s level of service and it’s contextual to their environment.
  • Home Network Management – Finally we live in the age of digital ubiquity! After being promised the digital home for the last 10 years in the last two it’s started to become a reality. Multiple PCs, laptops, networked storage systems, media centers, wireless routers, PDAs, smart phones, internet radio, gaming consoles, digital photo frames and print sharing are all becoming commonplace. However, installation, management and support of these devices and services are not. A 2nd generation desktop agent needs to be able to detect these local area network elements, help the subscriber configure them and provide local area network support. It also needs to provide the call center agent information that allows for application based visualization of a customer’s home network.

2nd generation agents can act as a powerful service and sales channel tool. A DSP that’s serious about differentiating themselves from their competition on the basis of service should be looking closely at this technology and evaluating the value it can provide for them.

If you have any questions regarding desktop agents, contact the Digital Optimist at orhan.ertughrul@consona.com.

Subscriber Activation - Part 2

Welcome to the second of our blogs on subscriber activation. This month we’re looking at the complex subject of CPE configuration and management.

 

If we step back in time around five years ago the subject of customer premise equipment (CPE) configuration and management was important to digital service providers but arguably far less vital than it is today. DSPs have always struggled with the issues around configuration and management of diverse CPE. However, the development of the broadband forum’s standards (TR 69, 64, 111 and 176) for ADSL CPE management and the increasing popularity of VoIP and IPTV have necessitated that more sophisticated systems for CPE management be developed.

 

For today’s ADSL broadband customer, activation means more than just setting up their PC. It means activating their gateway with services, security and quality of service (QoS) parameters, possibly configuring IPTV or VoIP equipment, and potentially even activating other devices on their network. To enable this, an auto-configuration server (ACS) is required and we shall look at some of the challenges it overcomes below.  But first, let me share with you a story that will set the stage for why an ACS is so important. 

 

A large UK company had a vulnerability revealed in its home gateway in 2007 that allowed for “eavesdropping, caller spoofing and other nasty attacks”. Fortunately the company in question had an ACS and so was able to rapidly update their deployed gateways, but what would have happened had they not had this facility? How would they have updated the 100s of thousands of gateways they had deployed? Recall? Disk based upgrade? Outbound calling to customers? What about the impact on brand equity and customer satisfaction? The impact to them as an organization would have been significant, in the 10s of millions of pounds. This is an extreme case but organizations suffer similar medium and low impact events on a regular basis all of which have a cost associated with them. Implementation of an ACS can be seen as an insurance policy that pays dividend when something like this occurs and can be quickly resolved.

 


Having the soft touch

 

If you’re managing activation of services in a customer’s home then there are probably four things that are of utmost importance to you:

Customer experience – First and foremost you want your new subscriber to have a great installation experience. This will determine their attitude to you and ultimately even contribute to whether or not you retain them as a customer. It’s far easier to create an initial good customer experience than to attempt to repair a bad relationship created by a poor customer experience.

 

Installation quality – The quality of any installation can have a long term impact on the quality of service a subscriber receives. Detecting problems at point of install that can then be rapidly solved by an engineer prior to him leaving the customer’s property is likely to have a very beneficial impact on the customer’s satisfaction with your service.

 

Time! – If you’re conducting engineer installs, time *is* money. A lot of DSPs use third party engineers to conduct installations. Simply rolling a truck to a customer’s home is likely to set you back $ 50 - $ 100 before you start to account for any extra time the engineer has to spend at the customer’s location.

 

On-going maintenance – Whatever CPE is installed at the customer’s home you want to be able to continue to maintain it once you’ve left the customer’s location. Part of this is simply being able to update modems with new firmware but there is also the requirement to be able to enact service policies such as bandwidth usage, user quarantine, abuse management and security management.

Motivated by Installation

 

I have found that there are three primary motivators of customer satisfaction with an installation:  simplicity, reliability and speed.

 

SIMPLICITY:  Zero-touch configuration allows the customer to simply connect the device to the network and an ACS automatically triggers power cycling of the device, enables services and triggers any required provisioning. The customer is oblivious to any of this, they just knows that their device works immediately (or very nearly so) without them needing to go through a complex set up procedure.

 

RELIABILITY:  Zero-touch configuration delivers reproducibility and removes the potential for human error ensuring that every installation follows a distinct and known path. This contributes to a high quality of installation. It also has the ability to look at modem parameters such as line attenuation (the degradation of signal to a modem generally due to distance and physical line characteristics). This can give an engineer or call center representative a clear indication of whether the quality of an installation is good and allow them to take immediate action to improve the line quality if required.

 

SPEED:  Zero-touch provisioning also potentially means not having to role a truck, or at the very least, significantly cutting down on the amount of time an engineer spends at a customer’s home. To understand the impact of this, imagine for a moment that you have a DSP that is doing 30,000 IPTV installs a month at a truck roll cost of $100 per truck roll. Remove the need for this truck roll and you’re instantly saving $3 M a month or $36 M a year. Even halving the time an engineer has to spend at a customer home would have a significant impact on costs.

 

Closing Thoughts

 

Although not strictly part of the activation process the foundation for on-going maintenance is laid down during activation. The use of an ACS to activate gateways or other LAN devices means that they can be connected to thereafter for maintenance activities. In my mind this is the single most important activation benefit that an ACS provides, not only does it allow for the auto provision of new, free and paid services but it also allows for the automatic update of devices as seen in my earlier story.

 

So to summarize, a good DSP activation process has a number of requirements that necessitate the implementation of automated systems. A combination of disk based install and an auto-configuration server provides a flexible solution that meets the majority of these needs.

 

If you have any questions regarding activation you can contact the Digital Optimist at orhan.ertughrul@consona.com. Or for more information on how Consona can help you implement a market leading activation process contact us and we’ll be happy to help you.

Subscriber Activation - Part 1

This month we’re tackling the issue of activating the subscriber. This will be a two part blog which will cover disk activation systems this month and auto-configuration servers next month.

 

Broadband is now a mass market product where customers expect installation of their connectivity and configuration of their basic services to be quick and easy.  And although the subject of activating a subscriber may seem a little mundane, I believe it’s one of the most exciting parts of the customer lifecycle and one which relatively little investment is made by digital service providers. A couple of years back I worked with a large UK organization who didn’t even have an install process per se. They simply pre-provisioned the customer’s modem and gave them a single printed sheet with instructions on how to set up their email. Perhaps unsurprisingly they weren’t growing the subscriber base according to their projections.

 

A well thought through activation process can reduce costs, improve subscriber retention, differentiate your service from that of your competitors and generate revenue; issues which every digital service provider is struggling with. This blog entry will look at some of the best practices associated with activation.

 

 

Making Activation Work For You

Ask the majority of employees in a digital service provider organisation what the activation process is for and in around 90% of cases you’ll get the same answer “It’s for getting the subscriber connected to our network and activating services they want.” This is primarily true but it drastically underestimates the importance of activation in your organization. In the case above your activation process is relegated to the position of a necessity instead of it being viewed as a substantial asset.

 

So what should an install process be doing? Rather than splitting down our list functionally like most approaches I’ve seen, we’ll take a look at this based on digital service provider strategic objectives:

 

Cost reduction – First and foremost your installation process should get your subscriber installed quickly and without problems. This means having enough intelligence built into your system such that a problem can be identified and resolved without the subscriber having recourse to call the help desk. This is where I favour disk installation systems that have part of their installation process online within a walled garden, to a diskless system. There are some Internet connectivity issues that you simply can’t resolve with a diskless system, such as a PC Internet configuration problem. The system should also gather and present to the customer enough information so that if he can’t get connected they are armed with the correct information should they have to call the help desk.

 

However, if this is as far as our cost reduction initiative goes then we’re missing a trick. Now is the time to introduce the subscriber to lifetime self-care services. In introducing them to what the online self-care resources have to offer (possible through the medium of a flash movie) and installing pro-active support applications on their desktop you’re setting them up from the start to be less of a burden on your help desk.

 

Retention – One of the primary barriers to subscribers switching their digital service provider are the services that they are using, and most notably email. The more services you can persuade a customer to adopt at installation the less likely they will be to churn. Imagine the situation where a customer uses your email system, online storage, white-labeled security solution and online photo album. What will be their propensity to churn compared to a customer who simply has Internet connectivity. The adoption of so-called “sticky” services is key to retaining customers and the beauty of this approach is that it is pre-emptive not reactive. It’s more expensive to try and keep a customer who is threatening to churn than to ensure that they don’t want to churn in the first place.

 

Revenue Generation – when a customer is installing their new broadband service they should be excited about the new service they’re getting. At this point additional value added services can be positioned which, if adopted by the user, can create incremental revenue streams and have the additional benefit of improving retention as already noted. A typical approach might be to offer them several services (such as email) which they receive for free in addition to a variety of paid services. The customer can then pick and choose their service portfolio. With critical services such as Security it’s even possible to determine if a customer has a security product and offer them one if they don’t.

 

Again the ability to generate revenue through your install process doesn’t end here. With the installation of a desk-top service agent you continue to have the ability to offer contextual sales and upgrades throughout the lifetime of the customer by direct marketing to their desktop.

 

Differentiation – taking a “customer experience” approach to activation and the delivery of services, if done well, is a great start in differentiating your service from that of your competitors but there is also a secondary effect; in removing a segment of simply resolved activation issues from the help desk you allow the help desk to deal with providing a higher level of support for the more complex queries. In other words, instead of the help desk being mired down in triage they are able to concentrate on becoming trusted advisors to your subscribers and this also helps improve the customer experience.

 

Your activation process should always terminate in a customer questionnaire so that you have your customers’ opinion of your install process. This should advise further upgrades and adaptations to the activation solution.

 

I’d love to hear about the challenges you are facing as well as any success stories in your activation process.  Share your comments here or email The Digital Optimist directly at orhan.ertughrul@consona.com.

 

The Next Blog:  Subscriber Activation - Part 2

 

Don’t miss the second part of this series where I will cover another critical piece of the activation process - configuring and updating customer premise equipment such as modems, routers and set-top boxes to name a few.

 

Four Ways to Fall Flat on Your Face

Welcome to Episode 2 of the Consona DSP self-care blog series.

 

Dan Quayle, much loved by pundits worldwide for his turn of phrase, is reported to have said “If we don’t succeed then we run the risk of failure”. Although something of a truism his statement applies to the current provision of online services rather appropriately in as much as DSPs frequently don’t set themselves up to succeed in the first instance. Yankee believes that in the next three years there will be a continued shift of around 12% from traditional communication channels to online channels so it is, and will continue to be, important for DSPs to have effective online service channels. Episode 2 of the blog series looks at some of the typical online service channel pitfalls.

 

 

Why Support Services Deliver Poor Performance

Today almost all DSPs have online support channels of varying breadth and complexity. They offer a range of services such as:

 

·         Knowledgebase

·         “My Services” section for configuration and management of products and services

·         Auto-response

·         Community tools (chat, forums, tweets, etc.)

·         Automated fixes

·         Online incident submission

·         Resolution flows (case base reasoning tools)

 

Some DSPs have augmented these capabilities with PC resident software agents that automatically detect and resolve problems on a customer’s PC allowing for pro-active support.

 

Despite having a plethora of support tools at their disposal many DSPs I’ve talked to are dissatisfied with the performance of their online service channel. The problems generally fall into four main areas:

 

·         Relevance – The online service channel just doesn’t seem to “hit the sweet spot”— either the content isn’t relevant or it is not presented in a way that makes it easy to find. Relevancy may simply be a matter of how often the content is updated or whether the right services are on offer, but presentation is almost always down to design and navigation. Customers visit the site once, don’t find what they want, and so never return.

 

It is worthwhile noting that factors other than poor design and inadequate or out-of-date content can hamstring a online service channel; back end systems can contribute in not having the sophistication necessary to deliver advanced online services such as portfolio management or one-touch activation of new products or services.

 

·         Usage – People don’t visit the site because they don’t know it exists or can’t navigate to it from the DSPs home page. Sometimes this is simply down to poor navigation design but more often than not the customers don’t know the web site address and don’t know what service facilities it can provide. Often this is down to a failure to market the web site and its services appropriately during the customer’s installation and thereafter.

 

·         Assessment – This tends to be a bugbear for many people responsible for online support projects. Frequently financial assessment of performance is conducted once per year and generally around budget time. In other words, assessment is linked to the following year’s budget. However, unless assessment is a structural component of your online service channel program it can be very hard to do a last minute assessment of performance that produces convincing results.

 

·         Continuity – Almost every DSP I’ve worked with in the past 18 months has had a rotation of management staff responsible for self-care. This turnover creates a real issue for self-care programs. There is always a learning period involved with moving into a new position and without adequate handover processes there can be a lack of consistent vision. This isn’t helped by the fact that most online support departments are very small normally only consisting of two or three full time employees.

 

Despite these issues every DSP still retains their self-care resources largely because they believe that it may be doing *something* and have the hope that it could do more, although the fact that all their competitors offer this as a service also argues against its removal.

 

I believe that despite past experiences this hope is well founded but it does require that DSPs concentrate on resolving some of the issues that beset self-care programs. If you’ve fallen prey to any of the above pitfalls I’d be very interested to hear your experiences.  Share your comments here or  email The Digital Optimist directly at orhan.ertughrul@consona.com.

 

The Triumph of Hope Over Experience

Welcome to Episode 1 of the Consona DSP self-care blog series entitled the Digital Optimist.

 

Samuel Johnston once famously stated that “A second marriage is the triumph of hope over experience”. Sometimes, looking at the deployment of automated self care systems within digital service providers (DSPs) I find I have a similar feeling. It’s not that the initial deployments aren’t accomplished or that the information found within isn’t of a high quality but often, by the DSPs own admission, the impact is poor.

 

This series of blogs will look in detail at why DSPs build self-care systems, how they implement them, why they often deliver disappointing results and what can be done about it.

 

Why Build a Self Care System?

To begin to understand why this should be let’s pose a question, “Why do DSPs implement automated support systems”? The flippant answer is “to lower costs” but the actual reasons are a little more involved and complex. Most DSPs are struggling with a number of different technical, commercial and demographic changes that are impacting their businesses:

 

·         Complexity – When I started in the broadband business 10 years ago the few players in the European market had single flat fee broadband products and in the case of the company I worked for, cable TV and POTS (plain old telephone service). However, today we truly live in the age of digital ubiquity. Broadband products are multi-tiered with an array of value added services (VAS) that can be added to your internet access package. Digital TV and IPTV have come of age within the last three years bringing with them all the attendant operational challenges of interactive television. VoIP is now ubiquitous and with the recent advent of femto cell pilots fixed/mobile convergence has never been closer. WIMAX and 3G are starting a new revolution in wireless broadband connected PCs and devices and over 60 percent of households in Europe[1] now have home networks with multiple connected devices.

 

All this new complexity needs supporting and it is not commercially viable to continue adding new call centre representatives to meet the demand.

 

·         Commoditization – Certainly in the western world and increasingly in the affluent parts of Asia-Pacific, broadband is starting to be viewed as “just something I have to have.” In other words, it’s viewed as people would view gas, electricity or water; it’s become a commodity. Combine this with the deregulation of markets and anti-competition legislation, and the effect is highly competitive markets with aggressive pricing models. Lower prices mean lower average revenue per unit (ARPU) and that in turn puts pressure on the business to control costs.

 

·         Demographics – As broadband pushes deeper into late majority and laggard markets it penetrates sections of the community where understanding of technology is poorer than in those who were quick to adopt the new technologies. As your broadband market matures there is a high probability that the demands made on your call center will increase.

 

·         Expectations – The early broadband customer base was happy simply that they received a broadband service at all. Some immediacy of service was expected, but it was generally accepted that however bad the service was, it was still far better than narrowband. Today, the customer base is much more demanding and in line with the commoditization of the products, customers expect broadband to work and work well continuously. They also expect their DSP to be able to help them with any problems relating to value added services the DSP provides, even if the DSP has explained in the literature that someone else is really responsible for the support. They don’t want to wait, don’t want to be caught up in some interminable IVR, and they want to choose how they get service from you. As online and community support have become prevalent, their expectation is that any “good” company would provide this channel.

 

The impact of these four drivers is that DSPs have to find a way to provide a higher level of service for their customers if they want to remain competitive but, at the same time they need to lower effective support cost per subscriber. This leaves DSPs with what appears, on the face of it, an insurmountable problem; how do you lower support costs but give higher levels of service? The answer that most DSPs have at least partially turned to is “self-care”, the ability to divert people to a web-site or desk-top resident application in order to solve their problems and prevent them calling the call center.

 

Next Month’s Blog: Four Ways to Fall Flat on Your Face

 

A brief description of a typical DSP self-care system and a discussion of the issues that often prevent them from being successful.

 



[1] Parks Associates - Europe Home Network Update April 2008